Restaurant Review – Shabu-ya
Shabu-Ya
57 JFK St
Cambridge, MA 02138
www.shabuyarestaurant.com
Dancing visions of thinly sliced rib eye and steaming hot pots of vegetables simmering away in a rich broth enticed d. and me to venture out and try out Shabu-Ya in the square tonight.While the idea of having a shabu shabu restaurant so close to home was exciting, and the trendy, youthful restaurant decor was promising, all-in-all, we found that Shabu-Ya still has much room for improvement.
Cook-your-own food restaurants are always in a tough spot. There is no chef to work magic on the dish at the very end. And most diners like myself are far from being culinary masters. So it’s up to the restaurant to make sure that the quality and range of ingredients provided are so good in and of themselves so that even silly diners can throw everything together and still make something that tastes good in the end. And that’s a pretty tall order.
In the case of a shabu-shabu restaurant, this comes down to offering a rich soup-base and a variety of vegetables that will add the right complexity to the soup, so that diners can leave with full tummies and the final memory of noodles swimming in a delightfully rich broth at the very end. Because, as we all know, there really is nothing quite as anti-clamatic as a shabu-shabu that ends with a tasteless broth.
Shabu-ya unfortunately fell short in both respects; the soup-base lacked flavor, and the variety of vegetables offered, which primarily consisted of cabbage and bok choy added little depth to the soup. And so I must confess that while I was absolutely captivated by d.’s dinner conversation the entire time, I couldn’t help but daydream from time to time of an imaginary veggie patch from which I could pick just a small bit of asian turnip, a quarter of an onion, and a couple bits of ginger and garlic that I could slip into the soup. What wonders they could have done!
All in all, Shabu-ya’s enthusiastic owners, attentive servers, great location, and young decor give the restaurant great potential for success. To make sure it becomes a main staple in the competitive Harvard Square restaurant scene, they need to go back and improve upon the backbone of the restaurant – the shabu-shabu – by improving the broth, because really, a shabu-shabu restaurant with a bad soup is sorta like a steak house with a bad steak. And that’s just devastating.
Post/View Comments